The 7 Best Pizza Places in Reykjavik

Reykjavik offers a variety of pizza restaurants, from artisanal pizzas with a unique spin to traditional pies. Check out the list below to discover where to get the best pizza in Reykjavik.

Pizza certainly isn’t traditional Icelandic cuisine, but it’s extremely popular. It’s one of the county’s favorite fast foods, especially in Reykjavik. However, the spots featured on this list don’t take a fast-food approach to pizza-making. They’ve perfected their art and are serving up the top pizzas in the city.

Many travelers who embark on Reykjavik tours or join food and drink tours find themselves pleasantly surprised by the city’s thriving pizza scene. Whether you’re a pizza freak looking for perfection or need a quick bite during a jam-packed itinerary, this list has something for you.

Photo above by Ivan Torres

7. Reykjavik Pizzeria

Photo taken from Reykjavik Pizzeria.

Known for their fire-baked pizzas, Reykjavik Pizzeria is in a quiet neighborhood close to the city center. They take a no-nonsense approach, offering a wide selection of pizzas at affordable prices.

Their menu is full of traditional pies for those who like traditional pizza and unique ingredients for the more adventurous eater. Toppings like mussels, scallops, cream cheese, and snails show their pizza-making versatility. They also have several unique vegan and vegetarian pizzas.

Along with their impressive menu, Reykjavik Pizza offers a selection of wine, beer, and coffee. Stop in for a bite to eat and a beverage before hitting the city again. You can also order online for pick-up.

6. Olifa La Madre

Photo taken from Olifa La Madre.

Want to go gourmet? Olifa La Madre is known as Iceland’s first Pala pizza restaurant. This traditional Roman-style pizza has a crispy crust that stays soft and airy on the inside.

Olifa La Madre uses sourdough for its crusts and organic pelati tomatoes for its sauce. They only use the highest-quality organic ingredients and offer vegan and vegetarian options.

Prices at Olifa La Madre are a bit higher, but it’s well worth it. They offer a winter menu and feature lunch specials from Tuesday to Friday. You can book in advance to secure a table or order takeout and enjoy your pizza in nearby Laugardalur Park.

5. Eldofninn

Photo taken from Eldofninn Pizzeria.

This popular family-owned pizza joint takes pride in making everything from scratch using the finest local ingredients. Eldofninn cooks their pizzas in a wood-fire stone oven imported from Italy. They also spin their delicious pizzas on a stone plate to ensure they’re even on all sides.

Their menu is gigantic, featuring classics like the margarita and unique options such as their surf ‘n' turf pizza that includes shrimp and ground beef. They also offer plenty of vegetarian and vegan choices.

Situated in the suburbs of Reykjavik, Eldofninn is the perfect location to pick up a pizza after a visit to Laugardalslaug Swimming Pool, but keep in mind that they’re closed on Mondays.

This restaurant fills up quickly. During dinner hours on weekends, the wait could be an hour for takeaway or a table. They don’t take reservations, so plan ahead if you want to enjoy the authentic experience.

4. Hornid

Hornid was established in 1979, making it Reykjavik's first and longest-running Italian restaurant. Situated on the bustling Hafnarstraeti Street in the downtown area, Hornid operates out of its traditional (and distinct) yellow building—you can’t miss it.

Renowned for its fresh ingredients and delicious pizzas with expertly cooked thin crusts, Hornid is a perfect spot for families and those on a budget. Plus, their portion sizes are ample, so you’re guaranteed to leave satisfied.

Their menu includes pizza, pasta, and seafood dishes. Try the Pizza Pescatore, a seafood pizza with shrimp, mussels, and scallops—you don't want to get this close to the sea without tasting it. They also serve outstanding coffee.

Hornid is located by the Reykjavik Harbor, making it an ideal stop for dinner after a day of exploring or before a night out. The atmosphere inside is cozy and casual.

3. Daddi’ s Pizza

Daddi’s Pizza is an excellent family-owned pizzeria in Reykjavik serving hand-tossed pies in a relaxing setting. Conveniently located in the heart of the city, Daddi’s is a go-to spot for families or solo travelers looking for a high-quality meal at a reasonable price.

There’s something for everyone at Daddi’s Pizza. They offer over 30 toppings to choose from, along with specialty pies, breadsticks, and beverages.

Daddi’s is close to many top Reykjavik attractions, including Hlemmur Square and Klambratun Park. Break up your day of sightseeing by dining in or ordering your pizza to go and enjoying it outside on a sunny day.

You can also try Daddi’s Pizza while visiting Myvatn Lake. They have a location about 1 mile (2 kilometers) from the Ring Road, making it an ideal stop if you’re driving through North Iceland.

2. BakaBaka

BakaBaka is a charming culinary spot in Reykjavík’s oldest bakery, dating back to 1834. Located on Bankastraeti, it beautifully blends historic character with modern design. Rustic wood beams and cozy lighting create a warm, inviting space that shifts from relaxed to vibrant as the day progresses.

During the day, the cafe buzzes with locals enjoying flaky croissants, sourdough breads, and expertly brewed coffee. Everything is made in-house using Icelandic stone-milled flour. It’s the perfect place for a quiet breakfast or a midday break after strolling through downtown Reykjavik.

As evening falls, BakaBaka becomes a lively pizzeria and wine bar. Their sourdough pizzas feature bold, gourmet toppings like truffle, garlic, and wild mushrooms. A rotating list of natural wines complements the menu, making it a favorite for casual dinners and late-night bites.

Just steps away, you can visit the Hallgrimskirkja Church, Harpa Concert Hall, and the Sun Voyager sculpture. Whether you’re sightseeing, shopping on Laugavegur, or museum-hopping, BakaBaka offers a delicious pause in the heart of Reykjavik.

1. Flatey Pizza

Photo from Flatey.

The top spot on our list is Flatey Pizza, which excels at making traditional Neapolitan pizzas on homemade sourdough. They blast-cook their pies in an electric oven to ensure all ingredients are cooked to their highest potential.

Flatey Pizza prides itself on using only the freshest products, especially mozzarella. To make their irresistible Pizzaiola, all tomatoes are sourced directly from the farm. Their delicious pizza bases are made with Caputo Blue, a well-respected Neapolitan flour.

Their menu offers ten well-known and loved pizzas and the weekly specialty pizza, which is well worth a try. It’s definitely a hotspot for visitors and locals.

Flatey Pizza has multiple locations. Their elegant and trendy space by Grandi Harbor is a short walk from the city center. Check out the Whales of Iceland while you’re in the area.

Pizza Is Just the Tip of the Iceberg

Reykjavik boasts an exciting food scene, both for excellent Italian food but also all types of cuisines. If you’re a foodie planning your trip to the capital city, consider joining one of these food tours:

• Reykjavik Food Walk Tour — Explore local foods in this walking tour of Reykjavik, including 6 locations throughout the city.

• Small-Group Food Walking Tour in the Heart of Reykjavik — Embark on a 3-hour walking tour of authentic Icelandic cuisine and culture.

• Private 3-Hour Food Tour of Reykjavik — Follow your guide through this excursion around Reykjavik’s food scene.

Explore More of Reykjavik’s Food Culture

Reykjavik's pizza scene offers a diverse range of options, from traditional Neapolitan pies to innovative creations with local ingredients. Whether you prefer a quick slice or a gourmet experience, the city's pizzerias cater to all tastes and budgets.

Of course, there’s far more to food in Reykjavik than pizza. Want to learn more about Reykjavik’s food culture? Check out our Guide to Reykjavik Street Food or The Ultimate Vegan and Vegetarian Guide to Reykjavik.